Compare Project Insight, Smartsheet, and Basecamp

Pricing

 
PI#business™
$45
(Per user/per month) | 5 user minimum
Individual
$14
/ month
Basecamp Big
$3,000
per year
 
PI#team™
FREE
Unlimited Users
Business
$25
/month
Basecamp For Us
$29
per month
 
PI#enterprise™
$65
(Per user/per month) | 5 user minimum
Enterprise
Contact
for pricing
Basecamp With Clients
$79
per month
 
Free Trial
Free Trial
Free Trial Unavailable
Project Insight
PI#business™
$45 (Per user/per month) | 5 user minimum
PI#team™
FREEUnlimited Users
PI#enterprise™
$65 (Per user/per month) | 5 user minimum
Free Trial
Smartsheet
Individual
$14/ month
Business
$25/month
Enterprise
Contactfor pricing
Free Trial
Basecamp
Basecamp Big
$3,000per year
Basecamp For Us
$29per month
Basecamp With Clients
$79per month
Free Trial Unavailable

Ratings

Meets Requirements
Meets Requirements
7.4
8.4
8.3
Ease of Use
Ease of Use
6.5
8.2
8.5
Ease of Setup
Ease of SetupNot enough data available
8.4
8.7
Ease of Admin
Ease of AdminNot enough data available
8.5
8.6
Quality of Support
Quality of Support
7.4
8.2
8.2
Ease of Doing Business With
Ease of Doing Business WithNot enough data available
8.5
8.7
Product Direction (% positive)
Product Direction (% positive)
7.4
7.8
7.3
Meets Requirements
Project Insight
7.4
Smartsheet
8.4
Basecamp
8.3
Ease of Use
Project Insight
6.5
Smartsheet
8.2
Basecamp
8.5
Ease of Setup
Project Insight
Not enough data available
Smartsheet
8.4
Basecamp
8.7
Ease of Admin
Project Insight
Not enough data available
Smartsheet
8.5
Basecamp
8.6
Quality of Support
Project Insight
7.4
Smartsheet
8.2
Basecamp
8.2
Ease of Doing Business With
Project Insight
Not enough data available
Smartsheet
8.5
Basecamp
8.7
Product Direction (% positive)
Project Insight
7.4
Smartsheet
7.8
Basecamp
7.3

Features

Tasks
Task Creation and Assignment
Project Insight
8.3
Smartsheet
8.7
Basecamp
8.8
Due Dates
Project Insight
8.5
Smartsheet
8.8
Basecamp
8.7
Task Prioritization
Project Insight
8.3
Smartsheet
8.5
Basecamp
7.7
To-Do Lists
Project Insight
7.4
Smartsheet
8.5
Basecamp
8.7
Collaboration
Collaborative Project Planning
Project Insight
7.7
Smartsheet
8.7
Basecamp
8.7
Comments
Project Insight
7.1
Smartsheet
8.2
Basecamp
8.7
Documents and Uploads
Project Insight
8.3
Smartsheet
8.4
Basecamp
8.6
Projects
Gantt Chart / Project Map
Project Insight
7.6
Smartsheet
8.5
Basecamp
6.6
Calendar View
Project Insight
8.3
Smartsheet
8.1
Basecamp
7.6
Baselining / KPIs
Project Insight
7.3
Smartsheet
7.5
Basecamp
6.8
Project Budgeting
Project Insight
7.4
Smartsheet
7.7
Basecamp
6.6
Issue Tracking
Project Insight
7.9
Smartsheet
7.9
Basecamp
7.5
Portfolio Management
Portfolio Coordination
Project Insight
8.9
Smartsheet
8.0
Basecamp
7.8
Portfolio Budgeting
Project Insight
8.3
Smartsheet
7.8
Basecamp
7.1
What-If Scenarios
Project Insight
Not enough data available
Smartsheet
7.3
Basecamp
7.0
Workflow
Project Insight
8.9
Smartsheet
8.2
Basecamp
7.9
Request Management
Project Insight
9.0
Smartsheet
8.0
Basecamp
7.7
Cost Tracking
Project Insight
8.3
Smartsheet
7.8
Basecamp
6.7
ROI and Forecasting
Project Insight
Not enough data available
Smartsheet
7.6
Basecamp
6.6
Risk Analysis
Project Insight
Not enough data available
Smartsheet
7.6
Basecamp
6.7
Resource Management
Resource Database
Project Insight
7.5
Smartsheet
7.9
Basecamp
7.6
Resource Allocation
Project Insight
8.1
Smartsheet
8.0
Basecamp
7.6
Workload Capacity
Project Insight
8.3
Smartsheet
8.1
Basecamp
7.7
Time Tracking
Project Insight
8.5
Smartsheet
8.0
Basecamp
7.5
Platform
Alerts
Project Insight
7.8
Smartsheet
8.2
Basecamp
8.4
Mobile
Project Insight
6.9
Smartsheet
7.8
Basecamp
8.1
User, Role, and Access Management
Project Insight
7.7
Smartsheet
8.4
Basecamp
8.4
API / Integrations
Project Insight
7.9
Smartsheet
7.4
Basecamp
7.5
Reporting and Dashboards
Project Insight
7.8
Smartsheet
7.9
Basecamp
7.8
Customization
Project Insight
6.7
Smartsheet
7.8
Basecamp
7.1
Performance and Reliability
Project Insight
7.0
Smartsheet
8.6
Basecamp
8.8

Reviewers' Company Size

Small-Business (50 or fewer emp.)
Small-Business
(50 or fewer emp.)
45.5%
32.2%
51.4%
Mid-Market (51-1000 emp.)
Mid-Market
(51-1000 emp.)
27.3%
38.2%
32.4%
Enterprise (> 1000 emp.)
Enterprise
(> 1000 emp.)
27.3%
29.6%
16.3%
Project Insight
Small-Business
45.5%
Mid-Market
27.3%
Enterprise
27.3%
Smartsheet
Small-Business
32.2%
Mid-Market
38.2%
Enterprise
29.6%
Basecamp
Small-Business
51.4%
Mid-Market
32.4%
Enterprise
16.3%

Reviewers' Industry

 
Construction
30.8%
Information Technology and Services
11.3%
Marketing and Advertising
16.5%
 
Internet
15.4%
Computer Software
7.8%
Information Technology and Services
6.8%
 
Information Technology and Services
15.4%
Marketing and Advertising
6.8%
Higher Education
6.6%
 
Higher Education
7.7%
Higher Education
5.6%
Non-Profit Organization Management
6.3%
 
Financial Services
7.7%
Hospital & Health Care
4.2%
Computer Software
5.7%
 
Other
23.1%
Other
64.4%
Other
58.0%
Project Insight
Construction
30.8%
Internet
15.4%
Information Technology and Services
15.4%
Higher Education
7.7%
Financial Services
7.7%
Other
23.1%
Smartsheet
Information Technology and Services
11.3%
Computer Software
7.8%
Marketing and Advertising
6.8%
Higher Education
5.6%
Hospital & Health Care
4.2%
Other
64.4%
Basecamp
Marketing and Advertising
16.5%
Information Technology and Services
6.8%
Higher Education
6.6%
Non-Profit Organization Management
6.3%
Computer Software
5.7%
Other
58.0%

Reviews

Most Helpful Favorable Review
Most Helpful Favorable Review
G2 Crowd User in Higher Education

I like the simplicity of the GUI that Project Insight offers. I also have come to like the timer feature that allows you to have the system count the time that will be designated toward a task. Once I have set the timer, I no longer have to take note of...

Scott B.
Consultant in Computer Software

SmartSheet's simplicity and intuitive design make it very easy to become productive very quickly. It combines the best aspects of Microsoft Excel like the ability to create complex formulas with the sharing, collaborative parts of Google spreadsheets.

G2 Crowd User in Internet

Caveman ready interface. It's like an apple product; crack it open and go.

Most Helpful Critical Review
Most Helpful Critical Review
G2 Crowd User in Internet

Time entry is a bit hard to do within the tool. I've used other programs such as Harvest and had a better user experience. To use Harvest as an example, there are dedicated apps that can run outside of the browser, that allow you to categorize your...

Jeff N.
Administrator

Slowest app to load, sometimes takes several reloads for app to become available. Slower than any other app I use. Downtime for maintenance. Have to log back in after maintenance. Adertisement banners appearing across top of page more and more. Can't merge...

Paul S.
Executive Sponsor in Marketing and Advertising

Things haven't evolved over the last couple years and now there are other options out there for managing projects and tracking time.

 
Project Insight
Most Helpful Favorable Review
G2 Crowd User in Higher Education

I like the simplicity of the GUI that Project Insight offers. I also have come to like the timer feature that allows you to have the system count the time that will be designated toward a task. Once I have set the timer, I no longer have to take note of...

Most Helpful Critical Review
G2 Crowd User in Internet

Time entry is a bit hard to do within the tool. I've used other programs such as Harvest and had a better user experience. To use Harvest as an example, there are dedicated apps that can run outside of the browser, that allow you to categorize your...

Smartsheet
Most Helpful Favorable Review
Scott B.
Consultant in Computer Software

SmartSheet's simplicity and intuitive design make it very easy to become productive very quickly. It combines the best aspects of Microsoft Excel like the ability to create complex formulas with the sharing, collaborative parts of Google spreadsheets.

Most Helpful Critical Review
Jeff N.
Administrator

Slowest app to load, sometimes takes several reloads for app to become available. Slower than any other app I use. Downtime for maintenance. Have to log back in after maintenance. Adertisement banners appearing across top of page more and more. Can't merge...

Basecamp
Most Helpful Favorable Review
G2 Crowd User in Internet

Caveman ready interface. It's like an apple product; crack it open and go.

Most Helpful Critical Review
Paul S.
Executive Sponsor in Marketing and Advertising

Things haven't evolved over the last couple years and now there are other options out there for managing projects and tracking time.

Screenshots

 
1 of 6
2 of 6
3 of 6
4 of 6
5 of 6
6 of 6
1 of 3
2 of 3
3 of 3

Videos

 No videos provided

See how Smartsheet works across an organization to make projects and team collaboration easy. Integration videos: JIRA, Salesforce, Microsoft O365, G Suite, Skype for Business and Microsoft Teams. Customer Videos: MOD Pizza, Cisco. Project Portfolio Managment in Smartsheet

No videos provided
Project Insight
No videos provided
Smartsheet

See how Smartsheet works across an organization to make projects and team collaboration easy. Integration videos: JIRA, Salesforce, Microsoft O365, G Suite, Skype for Business and Microsoft Teams. Customer Videos: MOD Pizza, Cisco. Project Portfolio Managment in Smartsheet

Basecamp
No videos provided

Downloads

 No downloads providedNo downloads provided
Project Insight
No downloads provided
Basecamp
No downloads provided
Ask Insight a QuestionContact InsightAsk Smartsheet a QuestionContact SmartsheetRequest More InformationRequest More Information